Today on CNN Newsroom

The latest news and information from around the world. Also connect with CNN through social media. We want to hear from you.
October 7th, 2011
01:09 PM ET

Civilian-military divide: Is it real? Does it matter?

Dave Schechter
Senior National Editor

If it is true that, "America doesn't know its military and the United States military doesn't know America,” as Adm. Mike Mullen, the recently-retired Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, warned earlier this year, why does this gulf exist?

Perhaps because only 1 percent of Americans serve in the military.

Perhaps because fewer than 8 percent of Americans are veterans (a fraction projected to grow smaller in the coming years).

Perhaps because today only one in five members of the U.S. House and Senate is a veteran, compared with three out of every four in 1969.

Military families feel a divide. In a survey conducted last year by Blue Star Families, 92 percent of 3,600 military family members who responded agreed that the general public neither understands nor appreciates the sacrifices made by service members and their families.

And if you have that appreciation, does it suffice to say “thank you for your service” when meeting a member of the armed forces? Is it enough to applaud when you see uniformed military walking through an airport? Is it enough to stand and cheer when wounded troops are introduced at a baseball game? Is it enough that warm-and-fuzzy images of troops coming home are woven into television commercials?

What is enough?

Elizabeth Samet, a professor of English at the U.S. Military Academy in West Point, New York, reviewed the “street theater” that ensues when civilians encounter uniformed military personnel: “One former captain I know proposed that ‘thank you for your service’ has become “an obligatory salutation. Dutifully offered by strangers, ‘somewhere between an afterthought and heartfelt appreciation,’ it is gratifying but also embarrassing to a soldier with a strong sense of modesty and professionalism. ‘People thank me for my service,’ another officer noted, ‘but they don’t really know what I’ve done.’ . . . These transactions resemble celebrity sightings - with the same awkwardness, enthusiasm and suspension of normal expectations about privacy and personal space. Yet while the celebrity is an individual recognized for a unique, highly publicized performance, the soldier is anonymous, a symbol of an aggregate. His or her performance is unseen.”

In a speech a year ago Duke University, then-Defense Secretary Robert Gates lamented a growing divide. “Whatever their fond sentiments for men and women in uniform, for most Americans the wars remain an abstraction. A distant and unpleasant series of news items that do not affect them personally. Even after 9/11, in the absence of a draft, for a growing number of Americans, service in the military, no matter how laudable, has become something for other people to do.“ In fact, with each passing decade, fewer and fewer Americans know someone with experience in the military or in their social circle,” Gates told his audience.

A skeptical review of Gates' comments was published soon after on The Moderate Voice website, where Logan Penza wrote that "all the way back to the founding of the republic run fears about a professional military class that, isolated and removed from the broader society, would be prone to take over and short-circuit democracy." Penza refered to the idea of gap between the civilian and military worlds as " . . . a classic boogyman. It is a scary but ultimately fictional concept occasionally rolled out in hopes that it will provide motivation for some hoped-for policy change or proposal," such as a return of the draft.

Penza also wrote that, “Public respect for the military has been sky-high (especially compared to other government institutions) during precisely the same periods that concern about the “gap” is greatest.”

Rebekah Sanderlin is an Army wife living in Fayetteville, North Carolina, home to the Army’s Fort Bragg. She also is a former newspaper reporter who writes a blog on military family life. Her first encounter with a mass demonstration of public support for the military came this past summer at a country music concert in a large stadium in Nashville. When a performer’s remarks “caused the crowd to rise in a spontaneous standing ovation for the military,” Sanderlin told CNN, “I was so touched that I started to cry,” a reaction that surprised Sanderlin’s mother. “I told her it was because I've never seen that before. ‘But Rebekah, she said, ‘they do that all the time, at every concert and every game.’ I didn't doubt what she said was true and I've gotten enough mass emails about shows of military support that I know, intellectually, that the support is there. But in a decade of war, I'd never SEEN it for myself.”

Sanderlin, whose husband has deployed several times in the past decade, added, “To civilians living in a world where there are frequent and large scale shows of military support, talking about a military-civilian divide rings false to them. They don't see it because they see military support all the time, everywhere they go. The problem is that our culture is so divided geographically and economically that the average military family can't afford . . . to be in the places where the support is shown. And military spouses are virtually impossible to identify, so we're very difficult to ‘support’.”

Heather Sweeney, another military wife, offered an olive branch in a newspaper blog: “In a way, I can’t blame civilians for their lack of awareness. After all, before my husband joined the military I had no idea what it meant to be a military spouse. I had no clue about the sacrifices we would both be making in the name of patriotism, nor did I anticipate the challenges of the lifestyle I had unwittingly agreed to when my husband raised his right hand and took that oath. Everything I know about military life is through personal experience and the adventures I’ve lived vicariously through other military spouses. But for people who can’t experience the lifestyle themselves or through a friend or family member, it’s easy to overlook the military population.”

Several of the comments after Sweeney’s blog suggested that resumption of a military draft – an idea rejected by the Pentagon’s military and civilian leadership – would solve this problem by acquainting a broader cross-section of America to the challenges of military life.

The authors of “AWOL: The Unexcused Absence of America’s Upper Classes from Military Service and How It Hurts Our Country,” pointed to a need for more of the best-and-brightest to make a career in the military, suggesting that more parents and teachers should encourage college-educated young people to consider a life in uniform.

The book’s co-author, Kathy Roth-Douquet – the wife of a Marine Corps officer, a former Defense Department official and a co-founder of Blue Star Families – spoke to this issue a couple of years ago at Columbia University, when the proposed return to campus of the Reserve Officer Training Corps program was being debated. “The university unabashedly seeks to educate opinion-shapers and decision-makers for the generations, yet those very people are the ones that are most inadequately prepared to lead the military. The genteel distain for military service and the intellectually-dishonest dodges for educating military officers contribute mightily to a situation where the deciders throughout society largely do not understand what it is the doers do,” Roth-Douquet said. [Note: Columbia approved return of the ROTC earlier this year.]

Today’s public displays of support for the military are a change from the atmosphere 40 years ago, when the Vietnam War caused bitter divisions in society. Now, the city of Fayetteville, North Carolina, is inviting men and women who served in Vietnam – especially the 200,000 came through Fort Bragg – to visit in November for a 10-day “Heroes Homecoming,” an event “designed to give Vietnam Vets the thank you they never got back then,” Sanderlin, who serves on the planning committee. In this way, those veterans will get a taste of what has become commonplace over the past decade.

Filed under: CNN Newsroom
soundoff (10 Responses)
  1. zORG

    I am a child of the military. I know first hand how it is to have a father serve 22 years faithfully and with no parades. I have 3 siblings that are in active duty. I ask the question that never gets asked. Do soldiers know what civilians do every day to allow th earmed forces to exist? Do they understand that our tax dollars pay their checks, their disability, their retirement, their counciling and their families livelyhood. The true disconnect is that most civilians do not understnad what soldiers go through day in and day out. But also that soldiers forget what it is to be a civilian. Kinda like the saying about house wives could be said about civilians, we may be home, but don't think our lives are any easier. Ask a soldier how easy it is to become a civilian. take that survey.

    July 11, 2013 at 4:40 pm |
  2. bang hieu quang cao

    Công ty Quảng Cáo Đại Phát cung cấp dịch vụ thiết kế, in ấn và thi công biển bảng quảng cáo,
    biển đèn led, chữ nổi, in ấn hiflex uy tín, chất lượng cùng giá thành cạnh tranh nhất trên thị trường tại
    khu vực TP. Hồ Chí Minh

    Làm bảng hiệu quảng cáo tphcm – Một bảng hiệu đẹp với thiết kế
    thu hút sẽ là lợi thế lớn của bạn trong việc quảng bá thương hiệu, và sản phẩm dịch vụ.

    Thiết kế, in ấn, thi công bảng biển hiệu quảng
    cáo đèn LED, chữ nổi Inox, đèn LED ma trận, mặt dựng alu,
    bảng hiệu, hộp đèn, tủ kệ nhôm kính giá rẻ.

    – gia cong mica
    – gia cong inox
    – lam bien quang cao

    Quang Cao Dai Phat
    Hotline: 0935 79 00 28

    January 22, 2021 at 7:54 am |
  3. pXOPbE3

    387622 245454I feel other site proprietors need to take this web site as an model, really clean and superb user genial style . 259302

    February 23, 2021 at 9:03 am |
  4. Quang Cao Dai Phat

    I just like the valuable information you supply for your articles.

    I'll bookmark your weblog and take a look at again right here frequently.
    I'm relatively sure I will be informed many new stuff right right here!
    Best of luck for the next!

    April 1, 2021 at 12:11 pm |
  5. Quang Cao Dai Phat

    Quang Cao Dai Phat

    April 7, 2021 at 4:12 pm |
  6. Quang Cao Dai Phat

    You should take part in a contest for one of the finest blogs on the
    net. I'm going to highly recommend this website!

    April 15, 2021 at 8:14 pm |
  7. espiar whatsapp

    420405 222966I like this internet site because so a lot utile stuff on here : D. 752706

    June 5, 2021 at 8:27 am |
  8. trực tiếp bong đá hôm nay

    Trực Tiếp Soccer Thời Điểm Hôm Nay, Links Xem Soccer Trực Tuyến 24hxem trực tuyến bóng đáV.League là giải đấu số một trong khối hệ thống giải bóng đá thường xuyên nghiệp nước ta. Ngoài ra, hàng loạt trận đấu của các giải World Cup, Asian Cup, SEA Games, vòng loại World Cup cũng thông thường xuyên được tiếp sóng trên đây. Trước đó, HLV trưởng Phạm Minh Giang đã chốt xong danh sách 14 cầu thủ tham dự 2 trận đấu với Lebanon. So với nhóm hình dự VCK futsal World Cup 2016

    June 10, 2021 at 4:32 am |
  9. W88casino

    333484 414470so significantly great information on here, : D. 135855

    June 15, 2021 at 5:51 am |
  10. 먹튀검증

    363058 560124Really informative post. Your current Site style is awesome as well! 191495

    June 21, 2021 at 9:45 pm |

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.